Theatre review: Sinners' fast-flying farce is full of naughty fun
At Metro Theatre, Norm Foster’s dark comedy features juicy twists and guilty pleasures

Jasmine Eadie and Josh Zumstien in Metro Theatre’s Sinners.
Sinners runs at Metro Theatre to February 15
SOMETIMES IT FEELS SO good to be bad. That’s why Metro Theatre’s production of Sinners hits in all the right ways.
For the duration of Canadian playwright Norm Foster’s two-act play, audiences get to enjoy politically incorrect jokes and plot points without feeling guilty. Under the direction of Angie McLeod, Sinners is a dark comedy full of juicy twists and so much suspense you’ll find yourself on the edge of your seat.
At the top of the show, we meet Monica Lloyd (Jasmine Eadie), the wife of the town reverend, welcoming Peter Kramer (Josh Zumstien) for a visit. The pair are having an affair, and with the minister scheduled to be out of town for a few days, Monica is sure that she and Peter are in the clear to have fun together. However, Peter has an uneasy feeling and his instincts will prove to be correct, with a number of surprising turns set to shake up the pair’s night. And despite the dark nature of some of these surprises, it’s all such riotous fun.
Nervous and rational, Zumstien’s Peter is a perfect foil to Eadie’s charismatic yet impulsive and reckless Monica. Both have sharp timing and ample physical-comedy skills. Equally engaging is the innocence of Colleen Brow as local townswoman Diane Gillis, who has some news to deliver that will, unbeknownst to her, have a major impact on the situation.
There’s a huge plot shift in the second act, and Foster’s script keeps you glued to the action as the details are gradually revealed. The addition of nosy Carolyn Cavanaugh (Deborah Tom) and her husband, police chief Roy Cavanaugh (Liam Reitsma), thickens the plot. Tom is fun to watch as she rifles through things, digging for dirt. And with his deadpan, matter-of-fact demeanour, Reitsma delivers some hilarious one-liners: “I’m the chief of police, I don’t have time for community involvement,” he says at one point, later explaining that running for mayor is “the next best thing to retirement”.
McLeod keeps the farce’s rhythm quick-paced, never letting the proverbial ball drop. The cast keeps that momentum up, volleying a nonstop onslaught of jokes. All of this is played within Kathleen Hilton’s gorgeous and functional set, which uses a clever layout that keeps the house’s bedroom and living room in sight at all times. Some elements are intentionally tacky (the eyesore of a couch plays a big part of the show’s humour) or cheeky (a giant cross on the livingroom wall). However, the overall aesthetic is pleasing, including a glowing moon outside the home. Kelsey John Torok’s subtle lighting effects add an effective touch, helping to shift the action from one room to another.
Sinners is a wild and silly ride—a definite guilty pleasure. So, go ahead and indulge. This is your “hall pass” to revel in some naughty, mischievous fun.
Vince Kanasoot is a former professional dancer and musical theatre actor who performed for Princess Cruises and Royal Caribbean, as well as in musicals across Canada. He left the stage to pursue his love for writing, and now works full time in corporate communications, while also working on his first novel. Follow his adventures on Instagram @VanCityVince.
Related Articles
At the Firehall Arts Centre, Cree theatre artist journeys through her childhood memories, incorporating cheeky crowd work
All-ages show by Cause & Effect Circus incorporates high-level skills, inventive lighting, and fun sound effects
Justin Anthony directs the show about a group of survivors navigating the aftermath of a cataclysmic event
Howard Dai’s Dream Machine pulls inspiration from Taiwanese game shows, while Paige Louter’s Nod acknowledges chronic fatigue
1 Santosh Santosh 2 Go touches on the model minority myth with hilarity and heart
Set in Pacific Theatre’s activity room, play by Katherine Gauthier leans into realism with depth of character and lasting intensity
Newest production to feature Sound the Alarm’s lineup of seasoned singers mines soundtracks of Disney and Hollywood classics
The violinist’s Fantasy Vignettes interweaves Baroque music, costume changes, and sewing machines
On the BMO Mainstage, director Dean Paul Gibson puts an ’80s spin on this resonant tale of young love
Aussie troupe Gravity & Other Myths’ stripped-down spectacle has been a hit around the world
In Hair Hair Everywhere, Shabnam debates whether or not she should shave
In girl power–fuelled show, performers channel sounds of Beyoncé, Lily Allen, and more in turning the tables on doomed relationships
In Inner Elder at the Firehall Arts Centre, the Calgary-based theatre veteran draws on more than three decades of Indigenous clowning experience
Moving into ambitious new territory, the company meets the many challenges of the Broadway classic and its still-relevant message
Arts Club play edges true-life story of Princess Di hospice visit into unexpected transcendent realm
All is not as it seems as two of Shakespeare’s most tumultuous couples navigate secret love and mistaken identities
With its flared costumes and feisty performances, Metro Theatre’s production of a Rice and Lloyd Webber favourite offers a quirkily fun tour of musical genres
As storylines switch between playwrights and the characters they’ve created, this challenging Zee Zee Theatre production spotlights hidden disparities separating two best friends
Fast-rising Filipino-Canadian actor and singer-songwriter takes the titular role in a rendition set in a 1970s variety show
The transition follows her departure from Music on Main, where she served as artistic planning and operations manager for seven years
Playwright Katherine Gauthier’s fly-on-the-wall production at Pacific Theatre follows five people in a group therapy session as they exchange intimate thoughts
City council throws support behind feasibility study’s call for world-class mid-size venue and recital hall
Wild treadmill antics, nostalgic-’90s circus, and new work by the likes of Corey Payette, Carmen Aguirre, Anais West, Veda Hille, and Maiko Yamamoto
Zahida Rahemtulla’s new play reflects three versions of what it meant to hold things together during the 2016 refugee resettlement initiative
Western Gold Theatre finds unique paths through the mysteries of Caryl Churchill’s innovative play on aging and dying
At Progress Lab 1422, a pair of tracks feature multidisciplinary works by Howard Dai, Paige Louter, Cameron Peal, and more
Roster also includes the troupe’s 40th panto, Jack and the Beanstalk, plus Neil Simon, Lend Me a Tenor, Shakespeare in Love, and more
Ten episodes feature play excerpts and interviews with emerging theatre artists who identify with D/disability
Annual accolade honours an individual who has significantly enriched Metro Vancouver’s arts and culture community
Seventy years after the classic musical’s debut, its theme of love transcending hate continues to inspire performers and audiences