Music review: Passion meets precision as Vancouver Symphony Orchestra pulls off massive Carmina Burana
Vancouver Bach Choir vocal power, thundering percussion, and tight string section earn standing ovation


Vancouver Symphony Orchestra presents Carmina Burana at the Orpheum Theatre to February 25
WITH ITS EXTREMES of smashing percussion and susurrating strings, booming choruses and whispered incantations, Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana can be an unwieldy beast. But energized guest conductor Jordan de Souza brought extreme precision to the Vancouver Symphony Orchestra and the 150-strong Vancouver Bach Choir and Vancouver Bach Children’s Choir’s rendition of the German composer’s biggest hit—without sacrificing any of its strange and brash flourishes.
This is, after all, an often-bawdy work about the volatility of fate, and the ups and downs of drinking, lust, and wealth. Orff based his 1937 piece on the medieval poetry of the Goliards, monks disillusioned by moral corruption.
It’s a piece audiences know well—not just from their classical CD collection, but the cantata’s heavy rotation in movies and advertising. In other words, there’s an expectation that comes with Carmina Burana—and in this case, the crowd jumped to its feet for a standing ovation after the final, exhilarating extended chord.
De Souza’s attention to detail could be heard immediately in the opening “O Fortuna”, with its brisk and exacting tempo and the choir’s articulation in the hushed, warning repetitions.
The strings found all the detailed textures of Orff’s score, flowing and beautifully restrained in the quiet sections, slashing and stabbing in unison in others.
Principal percussionist Vern Griffiths and his team also deserved full props, as they wielded all manner of cymbals, bells, drums, and xylophones to bring the range of thundering pulses and otherworldly rattling to the piece. De Souza cued and silenced them to the millisecond, emphasizing the score’s rhythmic verve.
The three Canadian soloists were strong, soprano Tracy Dahl handing in a deeply expressive “In Trutina” and baritone James Westman hitting his stride in the Tavern and Court of Love sections. And celebrated BC tenor Benjamin Butterfield stole the show in the eerie yet satirical “Olim lacus colueram”, flapping his tux tails like the swan of the song, and pretending to cringe at the tune’s sudden bursts of percussion—even though he strained in the punishing higher notes.
For fans of this big, bold banger of the classical world, it’s worth catching the second performance tonight. It’s fun watching the multitude of elements come together live onstage—to discover the instruments that create some of Carmina’s weirder textures and to witness the raw power of the chorus’s crescendos. Most of all, though, it’s a kick to watch De Souza command these forces with such spirit. His body becomes the taut and rhythmically attuned centre of a dazzling storm.
Janet Smith is cofounder and editorial director of Stir. She is an award-winning arts journalist who has spent more than two decades immersed in Vancouver’s dance, screen, design, theatre, music, opera, and gallery scenes. She sits on the Vancouver Film Critics’ Circle.
Related Articles
B.C. surf-rockers Empanadas Ilegales, powerhouse Australian vocalist Lloyd Spiegel, and more will perform at the Fraser River Heritage Park from July 25 to 27
As part of Music on Main, the Mexican Canadian composer’s luminous works respond to current chaos and ancient ties to the natural world
Joan Blackman shares the stage with eight all-star musicians for a program of works by Haydn, Mozart, and Schubert
Most decorated female Latin Grammy winner in history and mind behind the beloved Chief Inspector Gamache series will appear in Vancouver this fall
Coastal Jazz also announced the second year of the New Improvisers Studio
Summer concerts return to Vancouver parks, plus the new year includes Steve Hackman’s epic synthesis of Radiohead’s seminal OK Computer with Brahms’s First Symphony
Vancouver concert is nearly sold out, but great seats are still up for grabs in Surrey
Also on the program at Holy Rosary Cathedral is Benevoli’s Missa Tu Es Petrus
Raised on bluegrass and the warmth of her Bowen Island community, the Montreal-based folksinger comes full circle with songs about close emotional bonds
Vancouver Bach Family of Choirs presents the emotional composition with text by English soldier and war poet Wilfred Owen
Formed by a pair of musical duos, the group blends jazz, tango, African, classical, and more through mutual trust and constant curiosity
In her vibrant new show, the Vancouver singer illuminates and performs the timeless, barrier-breaking music that built Berry Gordy’s sonic empire
Set of antique and newly composed music by Hyeronimus Kapsberger and Claudio Ambrosini evokes the sounds of Venice
The Smithers, B.C.-based artist brings his articulate blend of soul, funk, jazz, and pop sounds to Vancouver
Artists hitting the Performance Works stage include New Jazz Underground, Nubya Garcia, and more
Friends of Chamber Music program features works by Barber, Bartók, and Shostakovich with unique historical relevance
Look forward to tales of hanging in Greenwich Village and Laurel Canyon with the likes of Bob Dylan and Leonard Cohen
Adaptation of the original Broadway production journeys through different eras of the Man in Black’s life and music
Award-winning New York-based string players to perform works by Mozart, Beethoven, and American composer Billy Childs
French choreographer Hubert Hazebroucq performs 15th- and 16th-century dances to the sound of a live wind band
For this UBC Opera and Opera West collaboration, emerging stars take the lead in a classic story with a long history of fame and scandal
Group’s founder and artistic director Masa Ogawa talks compassion and connection ahead of Chan Centre presentation
The choral singer, composer, and musician will succeed long-time head and cofounder Morna Edmundson
Performances by Bakara Band, violinist Suzka Mares, and vocalist Andrea Superstein are in store at David Lam Park and beyond
Russian virtuoso’s passion for pianoforte revives original voice of such legendary 19th-century composers as Beethoven and Mendelssohn
Hailing from distant musical worlds, the group’s members honour tradition while seeking connection through cross-cultural experiment
Concert honours Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina’s 500th birthday with such favourites as “Sicut cervus” and “Missa Papae Marcelli”
Known for her lilting melodies and deeply felt lyrics about love, artist delivers a coming-of-age collection in debut album Leftovers
In Vancouver Recital Society concert, the talented 24-year-old plays alongside New York City–based collaborative pianist Sahun Sam Hong
Concert conducted by Paula DeWit features a special collection of Baroque instruments and 16 vocalists